Atiku’s Fuel Subsidy Plan Will Bankrupt Nigeria, Destroy Credit Rating — IMPI
By Crystalnews Admin
The Independent Media and Policy Initiative (IMPI) has warned that former Vice President Atiku Abubakar’s proposal to restore fuel subsidy if elected president could plunge Nigeria into another cycle of fiscal crisis, weaken investor confidence and ultimately bankrupt the country.
The policy think tank, in a statement signed by its Chairman, Dr Omoniyi Akinsiju, described the proposal as “populist” and a dangerous reversal of the economic reforms undertaken by the President Bola Tinubu administration.
According to IMPI, although a return to fuel subsidy could initially reduce pump prices, the policy would create significant long-term financial and economic distortions.
The group said Atiku’s proposal to re-regulate fuel prices would undermine the Petroleum Industry Act (PIA) 2021 by creating artificially low fuel prices, which could eventually trigger shortages and a resurgence of black-market activities.
“This reckless, populist proposal represents a dangerous step backwards and a financial trap that would bankrupt Nigeria, destroy the country’s sovereign credit ratings, and wipe out the economic progress made over the past three years,” IMPI said.
The think tank argued that fixing fuel prices would remove commercial incentives for marketers to distribute petroleum products to remote areas, resulting in supplies being concentrated in high-volume urban centres such as Lagos, Abuja, Kano and Port Harcourt.
It warned that motorists, farmers and transport operators in rural areas could then be forced to depend on informal fuel markets, with transport costs potentially rising by as much as 40 per cent above current deregulated rates.
According to IMPI, the situation could worsen food inflation in urban centres while reducing the profit margins of rural farmers.
The organisation further argued that a return to subsidy could create uncertainty among private investors and international capital providers by signalling that Nigeria’s petroleum pricing policies could be reversed for political reasons.
It said such uncertainty could affect funding for major infrastructure projects and undermine public-private partnerships.
IMPI also raised concerns over the possible impact of price controls on local refineries, particularly large private investments that depend on market-based pricing to service substantial commercial loans.
“Price caps hurt refinery margins,” the group said, warning that forcing refineries into politically determined pricing formulas could weaken their cash flows and increase the risk of non-performing loans in the banking sector.
The organisation also projected possible consequences for Nigeria’s sovereign credit rating, arguing that international rating agencies could view a return to price controls as evidence of policy instability.
It said such a development could trigger sell-offs in Nigerian Eurobonds, increase sovereign borrowing costs and make access to affordable international capital more difficult.
“While a capped budget framework limits open-ended liabilities, international rating agencies like Fitch and S&P focus heavily on structural policy reversals,” IMPI said.
The group further warned that the proposed model could affect Nigeria’s relationship with multilateral lenders, including the World Bank and the International Monetary Fund.
According to IMPI, state intervention to artificially reduce domestic energy prices could be viewed as a market distortion and potentially affect policy conditions attached to development financing.
It warned that any disruption to concessional financing could leave the government increasingly dependent on expensive domestic borrowing to fund critical infrastructure.
IMPI argued that Nigeria’s infrastructure deficit could not be sustainably addressed by returning to fiscal policies that contributed to the country’s previous economic difficulties.
It said Atiku’s proposed “Follow-the-Barrel” model, which would replace a direct cash subsidy with a discount on crude oil revenue, could recreate the cycle of using oil resources to provide short-term relief while sacrificing long-term investments in infrastructure and productivity.
“Reintroducing price controls, even under a production model, signals that Nigeria’s long-term investment rules are volatile. This policy shift would trigger sell-offs in Nigeria’s Eurobonds, spike sovereign yields and block the country from accessing affordable global capital,” the group said.
“Relatedly, the model aims to protect local refining, but price caps hurt refinery margins. Private mega-facilities such as the Dangote Refinery rely on global pricing logic to service their multi-billion-dollar commercial bank loans.
“Forcing refineries into complex pricing formulas increases regulatory risk, endangers their cash flows and threatens a rise in non-performing loans across the banking sector.
“On the global financing front, the World Bank and IMF evaluate actual market distortions rather than accounting labels. Because the model artificially lowers local energy prices through state intervention, it could breach policy conditions tied to outstanding World Bank Development Policy Financing.
“This could freeze ongoing concessional loan disbursements, forcing the government to fund basic public infrastructure through expensive domestic borrowing.”
IMPI maintained that Nigeria should sustain reforms aimed at strengthening roads, healthcare, schools, electricity infrastructure and productive capacity rather than return to what it described as unsustainable fuel subsidy policies.
It said the country’s long-term economic stability would depend on predictable policies capable of attracting private capital, supporting domestic production and reducing dependence on crude oil revenues.


