Lawyer Faults Kanu, Kyari Cases, Alleges Selective Application of La
By Our Correspondent
A legal practitioner, Onyedikachi Ifedi, has accused the Nigerian government of applying different legal standards in the cases involving detained Indigenous People of Biafra (IPOB) leader, Mazi Nnamdi Kanu, and suspended Deputy Commissioner of Police, DCP Abba Kyari.
Ifedi made the allegation in Part Four of his legal commentary series, titled “Omotosho’s Fourth Jurisdictional Failure:
The Hypocrisy of Selective Sovereignty,” in which he questioned the jurisdictional basis of Kanu’s trial and conviction by Justice James Omotosho of the Federal High Court, Abuja.
The lawyer argued that Nigeria’s handling of Kyari’s extradition proceedings contrasted with its treatment of Kanu, who was brought from Kenya to Nigeria in 2021 in circumstances that have been widely challenged as extraordinary rendition.
Citing Section 76(1)(d)(iii) of the Terrorism (Prevention and Prohibition) Act, 2022, Ifedi argued that the prosecution was required to establish the relevant statutory conditions for prosecuting conduct allegedly committed outside Nigeria.
He faulted the court for allegedly proceeding without determining whether the conduct in question also constituted an offence under Kenyan law, describing the issue as fundamental to the court’s jurisdiction.
Drawing a comparison with the extradition proceedings involving Kyari in Federal Republic of Nigeria v. DCP Abba Kyari, Suit No. FHC/ABJ/CS/249/2022, Ifedi said Nigeria relied on domestic judicial processes and statutory safeguards when resisting a United States request for Kyari’s extradition.
He argued that the government’s approach in Kyari’s case raised questions about its respect for the sovereignty of another country in Kanu’s case.
According to the lawyer, the contrasting approaches reflected what he described as the selective application of legal principles, alleging that the government invoked legal safeguards when they served its interests but failed to demonstrate similar regard for those principles in Kanu’s case.
Ifedi also questioned the prosecution’s handling of the charges against Kanu following his transfer from Kenya. He alleged that the prosecution moved away from the earlier treasonable-felony framework and introduced a 15-count terrorism charge under the 2022 Act.
He said the development raised questions about the legal basis for prosecuting allegations linked to conduct allegedly committed outside Nigeria.
“The existence of an earlier charge could not automatically confer jurisdiction over new allegations or cure any illegality associated with the manner in which a defendant was brought into the country,” he argued.
Ifedi maintained that the legality of Kanu’s transfer from Kenya and the question of the Nigerian court’s jurisdiction were distinct but related issues that required proper judicial consideration.
He further invoked the principles of territorial sovereignty and international comity, arguing that Nigeria should respect Kenya’s legal authority while asserting the supremacy of its own judicial system in extradition proceedings involving Nigerian officials.
The lawyer called for consistent application of legal principles, insisting that safeguards relied upon in extradition proceedings involving public officials should also be respected in cases involving politically sensitive defendants.


